The Rheumatologist
COVID-19 NewsACR Convergence
  • Connect with us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Feed
  • Home
  • Conditions
    • Rheumatoid Arthritis
    • SLE (Lupus)
    • Crystal Arthritis
      • Gout Resource Center
    • Spondyloarthritis
    • Osteoarthritis
    • Soft Tissue Pain
    • Scleroderma
    • Vasculitis
    • Systemic Inflammatory Syndromes
    • Guidelines
  • Resource Centers
    • Axial Spondyloarthritis Resource Center
    • Gout Resource Center
    • Psoriatic Arthritis Resource Center
    • Rheumatoid Arthritis Resource Center
    • Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Resource Center
  • Drug Updates
    • Biologics & Biosimilars
    • DMARDs & Immunosuppressives
    • Topical Drugs
    • Analgesics
    • Safety
    • Pharma Co. News
  • Professional Topics
    • Ethics
    • Legal
    • Legislation & Advocacy
    • Career Development
      • Certification
      • Education & Training
    • Awards
    • Profiles
    • President’s Perspective
    • Rheuminations
    • Interprofessional Perspective
  • Practice Management
    • Billing/Coding
    • Quality Assurance/Improvement
    • Workforce
    • Facility
    • Patient Perspective
    • Electronic Health Records
    • Apps
    • Information Technology
    • From the College
    • Multimedia
      • Audio
      • Video
  • Resources
    • Issue Archives
    • ACR Convergence
      • Gout Resource Center
      • Axial Spondyloarthritis Resource Center
      • Psoriatic Arthritis
      • Abstracts
      • Meeting Reports
      • ACR Convergence Home
    • American College of Rheumatology
    • ACR ExamRheum
    • Research Reviews
    • ACR Journals
      • Arthritis & Rheumatology
      • Arthritis Care & Research
      • ACR Open Rheumatology
    • Rheumatology Image Library
    • Treatment Guidelines
    • Rheumatology Research Foundation
    • Events
  • About Us
    • Mission/Vision
    • Meet the Authors
    • Meet the Editors
    • Contribute to The Rheumatologist
    • Subscription
    • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Search
You are here: Home / Articles / Knee Surgery for Pain May Not Be Worthwhile

Knee Surgery for Pain May Not Be Worthwhile

July 9, 2015 • By Lisa Rapaport

  • Tweet
  • Email
Print-Friendly Version / Save PDF

(Reuters Health)—Middle-aged and older adults with torn cartilage or painful arthritis in their knee are not likely to benefit from arthroscopic surgery, and could be harmed by it, a review of past studies hints.

You Might Also Like
  • Self-Reported Knee Instability After Surgery Linked to Pain & Limited Mobility
  • Knee Replacement Surgery Works, but So Can Nonsurgical Techniques
  • Surgery Won’t Help Degenerative Knee Problems

Researchers reviewed nine previous studies with a combined 1,270 patients and found the surgery no better than other options like exercise for improving physical function, and only temporarily more effective at easing knee pain.

ad goes here:advert-1
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

“Patients and doctors should seriously consider if this treatment is the right choice given that only a short-term marginal benefit can be expected and the procedure comes with risk of serious complications,” lead study author Jonas Thorlund, a sports science and biomechanics researcher at the University of Southern Denmark, said by email.

Worldwide, more than 4 million people undergo arthroscopic knee surgery each year, according to the American Orthopedic Society for Sports Medicine. While it’s minimally invasive, it’s not risk-free.

ad goes here:advert-2
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

Thorlund and colleagues reviewed previous research comparing patients receiving arthroscopic surgeries to remove damaged tissue or torn meniscus cartilage to control groups of people receiving interventions ranging from exercise to placebo surgery.

Across all the studies reviewed, the average age of patients ranged from about 50 to 63 years old. After surgery or the alternative treatment, follow-up in the studies ranged from three to 24 months.

For pain relief, researchers found a small, but statistically significant benefit from knee surgery after three months and six months, but not later, they report in the BMJ, online June 16.

ad goes here:advert-3
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

Over the time periods measured in the studies reviewed, there was no difference in physical function after surgical or nonsurgical interventions.

The most commonly reported side effect was deep venous thrombosis, which happened in about 4 patients out of every 1,000. Other serious side effects were infection, pulmonary embolisms and death.

Many of the studies reviewed didn’t compare people randomly assigned either to surgery or another option, making it hard to compare the safety of different alternatives, the authors acknowledge.

In addition, the exercise therapy component in some studies reviewed wasn’t enough activity or was done in addition to surgery, making it difficult to assess the benefit of physical therapy to address knee problems, they note.

Even so, the study findings add to a growing body of evidence that may be approaching a tipping point against arthroscopic knee surgery for pain, Andy Carr, director of the Botnar Research Center at the Oxford University Institute of Musculoskeletal Sciences, writes in an editorial accompanying the study.

Pages: 1 2 | Single Page

Filed Under: Conditions Tagged With: knee, Knee Osteoarthritis (OA), Pain, Rheumatiod arthritis, surgery

You Might Also Like:
  • Self-Reported Knee Instability After Surgery Linked to Pain & Limited Mobility
  • Knee Replacement Surgery Works, but So Can Nonsurgical Techniques
  • Surgery Won’t Help Degenerative Knee Problems
  • Sleep Therapy May Help Ease Knee Pain

Rheumatology Research Foundation

The Foundation is the largest private funding source for rheumatology research and training in the U.S.

Learn more »

American College of Rheumatology

Visit the official website for the American College of Rheumatology.

Visit the ACR »

Meeting Abstracts

Browse and search abstracts from the ACR Convergence and ACR/ARP Annual Meetings going back to 2012.

Visit the Abstracts site »

The Rheumatologist newsmagazine reports on issues and trends in the management and treatment of rheumatic diseases. The Rheumatologist reaches 11,500 rheumatologists, internists, orthopedic surgeons, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, nurses, and other healthcare professionals who practice, research, or teach in the field of rheumatology.

About Us / Contact Us / Advertise / Privacy Policy / Terms of Use / Cookie Preferences

  • Connect with us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Feed

Copyright © 2006–2023 American College of Rheumatology. All rights reserved.

ISSN 1931-3268 (print)
ISSN 1931-3209 (online)