The Rheumatologist
COVID-19 News
  • Connect with us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Feed
  • Home
  • Conditions
    • Rheumatoid Arthritis
    • SLE (Lupus)
    • Crystal Arthritis
      • Gout Resource Center
    • Spondyloarthritis
    • Osteoarthritis
    • Soft Tissue Pain
    • Scleroderma
    • Vasculitis
    • Systemic Inflammatory Syndromes
    • Guidelines
  • Resource Centers
    • Ankylosing Spondylitis Resource Center
    • Gout Resource Center
    • Rheumatoid Arthritis Resource Center
    • Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Resource Center
  • Drug Updates
    • Biologics & Biosimilars
    • DMARDs & Immunosuppressives
    • Topical Drugs
    • Analgesics
    • Safety
    • Pharma Co. News
  • Professional Topics
    • Ethics
    • Legal
    • Legislation & Advocacy
    • Career Development
      • Certification
      • Education & Training
    • Awards
    • Profiles
    • President’s Perspective
    • Rheuminations
  • Practice Management
    • Billing/Coding
    • Quality Assurance/Improvement
    • Workforce
    • Facility
    • Patient Perspective
    • Electronic Health Records
    • Apps
    • Information Technology
    • From the College
    • Multimedia
      • Audio
      • Video
  • Resources
    • Issue Archives
    • ACR Convergence
      • Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Resource Center
      • Rheumatoid Arthritis Resource Center
      • Gout Resource Center
      • Abstracts
      • Meeting Reports
      • ACR Convergence Home
    • American College of Rheumatology
    • ACR ExamRheum
    • Research Reviews
    • ACR Journals
      • Arthritis & Rheumatology
      • Arthritis Care & Research
      • ACR Open Rheumatology
    • Rheumatology Image Library
    • Treatment Guidelines
    • Rheumatology Research Foundation
    • Events
  • About Us
    • Mission/Vision
    • Meet the Authors
    • Meet the Editors
    • Contribute to The Rheumatologist
    • Subscription
    • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Search
You are here: Home / Articles / Concerns Arising over Increased Retractions in Scientific Articles

Concerns Arising over Increased Retractions in Scientific Articles

May 13, 2016 • By Kurt Ullman

  • Tweet
  • Email
Print-Friendly Version / Save PDF
Dusit/shutterstock.com

Dusit/shutterstock.com

The number of scientific articles retracted increased 10-fold between 1988 and 2008 (from 0.002% in the early 1980s to 0.02% in 2005–2009), according to a paper published in the Journal of Medical Ethics.1 The authors did note that the number of articles listed in Medline each year has also increased over time, from approximately 300,000 per year in the 1980s to more than 800,000 per year in 2009.

You Might Also Like
  • Applications Invited for Arthritis & Rheumatology Editor in Chief
  • Predatory Publishing: Know the Difference Between a Financial Scheme and Scholarly Dissemination
  • Women Lag Men as Lead Authors in Top Medical Journals
Explore This Issue
May 2016
Also By This Author
  • Genetics Suggest Adult & Child Arthritis Aren’t So Different

Concerns over the increasing number of retractions have also entered research in rheumatic disease. An article in the Journal of the American Medical Association on the effects of nitroglycerin ointment on bone density and strength in women originally published in 2011 was recently retracted after a committee at the lead author’s institution “found evidence of falsified and/or fabricated data.”2

ad goes here:advert-1
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

“By and large, those contributing to the medical literature advance our understanding and do phenomenal work making the world a better place for our patients,” says Marian T. Hannan, DSc, MPH, professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and editor in chief of Arthritis Care & Research (AC&R). “With any process, things can slip through, but with the two American College of Rheumatology [ACR] publications, we have our eyes open and minimize these concerns to the extent we can.”

Systems Closely Scrutinize Articles

Both AC&R and Arthritis & Rheumatology (A&R) have systems in place to closely scrutinize incoming articles for content, interest, significance and validity. This starts with the authors themselves.

ad goes here:advert-2
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

“Most articles have several authors due to the complexity of medical data,” says Richard Bucala, MD, PhD, professor of medicine/rheumatology at the Yale University School of Medicine and editor in chief of A&R. “All authors sign a statement acknowledging they are qualified as authors, have reviewed all of the data and personally stand by the findings in the paper.”

First Look by Editors & Editorial Boards

The first cut is usually with the editor in chief and the editorial boards of the journals. They evaluate the scientific merit, the innovation and the significance of the findings. Only 20–50% of submissions make it past this initial evaluation, an indication of how stringent the requirements are.

Articles are sent to an editorial assistant to make sure they are formatted properly. Then, they are run through a software program called iThenticate, which searches the medical literature for plagiarism. The next step is the most important—peer review.

ad goes here:advert-3
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

Peer Review an Important Step

“Like most upper-level medical journals, both of the ACR publications are peer reviewed,” says Dr. Bucala. “At least two, and sometimes more, experts look at the paper, the facts and the data, and give the editor assigned to that study their comments and critiques. When there is a need for statistical or other more specialized review, we have reviewers available as needed.”

Both AC&R & A&R have systems in place to closely scrutinize incoming articles for content, interest, significance & validity. This starts with the authors themselves.

All peer reviewers undergo an extensive vetting process of their own. Instead of picking the next person on the list, reviewers are assigned based on their expertise, both self-stated and published. Each is evaluated for the timeliness and thoroughness of their work after each assignment.

Pages: 1 2 | Single Page

Filed Under: Professional Topics Tagged With: Education, rheumatologists, rheumatology, scientific journalsIssue: May 2016

You Might Also Like:
  • Applications Invited for Arthritis & Rheumatology Editor in Chief
  • Predatory Publishing: Know the Difference Between a Financial Scheme and Scholarly Dissemination
  • Women Lag Men as Lead Authors in Top Medical Journals
  • Planning the ACR/ARHP Annual Scientific Meeting

Simple Tasks

Learn more about the ACR’s public awareness campaign and how you can get involved. Help increase visibility of rheumatic diseases and decrease the number of people left untreated.

Visit the Simple Tasks site »

ACR Convergence

Don’t miss rheumatology’s premier scientific meeting for anyone involved in research or the delivery of rheumatologic care or services.

Visit the ACR Convergence site »

Rheumatology Research Foundation

The Foundation is the largest private funding source for rheumatology research and training in the U.S.

Learn more »

The Rheumatologist newsmagazine reports on issues and trends in the management and treatment of rheumatic diseases. The Rheumatologist reaches 11,500 rheumatologists, internists, orthopedic surgeons, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, nurses, and other healthcare professionals who practice, research, or teach in the field of rheumatology.

About Us / Contact Us / Advertise / Privacy Policy / Terms of Use

  • Connect with us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Feed

Copyright © 2006–2021 American College of Rheumatology. All rights reserved.

ISSN 1931-3268 (print)
ISSN 1931-3209 (online)

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
This site uses cookies: Find out more.