The Rheumatologist
COVID-19 NewsACR Convergence
  • Connect with us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Feed
  • Home
  • Conditions
    • Rheumatoid Arthritis
    • SLE (Lupus)
    • Crystal Arthritis
      • Gout Resource Center
    • Spondyloarthritis
    • Osteoarthritis
    • Soft Tissue Pain
    • Scleroderma
    • Vasculitis
    • Systemic Inflammatory Syndromes
    • Guidelines
  • Resource Centers
    • Axial Spondyloarthritis Resource Center
    • Gout Resource Center
    • Psoriatic Arthritis Resource Center
    • Rheumatoid Arthritis Resource Center
    • Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Resource Center
  • Drug Updates
    • Biologics & Biosimilars
    • DMARDs & Immunosuppressives
    • Topical Drugs
    • Analgesics
    • Safety
    • Pharma Co. News
  • Professional Topics
    • Ethics
    • Legal
    • Legislation & Advocacy
    • Career Development
      • Certification
      • Education & Training
    • Awards
    • Profiles
    • President’s Perspective
    • Rheuminations
    • Interprofessional Perspective
  • Practice Management
    • Billing/Coding
    • Quality Assurance/Improvement
    • Workforce
    • Facility
    • Patient Perspective
    • Electronic Health Records
    • Apps
    • Information Technology
    • From the College
    • Multimedia
      • Audio
      • Video
  • Resources
    • Issue Archives
    • ACR Convergence
      • Gout Resource Center
      • Axial Spondyloarthritis Resource Center
      • Psoriatic Arthritis
      • Abstracts
      • Meeting Reports
      • ACR Convergence Home
    • American College of Rheumatology
    • ACR ExamRheum
    • Research Reviews
    • ACR Journals
      • Arthritis & Rheumatology
      • Arthritis Care & Research
      • ACR Open Rheumatology
    • Rheumatology Image Library
    • Treatment Guidelines
    • Rheumatology Research Foundation
    • Events
  • About Us
    • Mission/Vision
    • Meet the Authors
    • Meet the Editors
    • Contribute to The Rheumatologist
    • Subscription
    • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Search
You are here: Home / Articles / Does Secondary Gain Exist?

Does Secondary Gain Exist?

February 1, 2008 • By David S. Pisetsky, MD, PhD

  • Tweet
  • Email
Print-Friendly Version / Save PDF
David S. Pisetsky, MD, PhD

In this and two subsequent columns, I will discuss the concept of secondary gain as it applies to disability. My goal is to revise a view I long embraced and, indeed, promulgated enthusiastically to students, house officers, and fellows. On many occasions in my teaching clinic, I stated that the concept of secondary gain in disability is misleading if not erroneous because what can be labeled as gain in reality represents loss. Sometimes I was even more dogmatic and said that secondary gain does not exist.

You Might Also Like
  • Hospitalists Gain Insight on Signs, Symptoms of Infection Among Inpatients on Biologic Drugs
  • No Gain with Pain: Exercise & Physical Function in Patients with Rheumatic Disease
  • Rheumatologists Saw a Gain in Compensation in 2020
Explore This Issue
February 2008
Also By This Author
  • Waiting for The Big One

I have been off target in my views, misguided by an effort to develop a more fair-minded and compassionate approach to disability. In what I think will be a constructive effort at revisionism, I will advance another concept of secondary gain that, while nuanced, is hopefully more illuminating. I did not get the inspiration for another look at secondary gain from reading an article in a high-impact journal or hearing a lecture from a touted thought leader. Rather, I rethought my views during a piano concert by Leon Fleisher, a virtuoso with a troubled right hand.

ad goes here:advert-1
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

Subjective Pain and Secondary Gain

Like virtually every rheumatologist I know, I have evaluated patients who seek disability despite minimal signs of arthritis or musculoskeletal disease. Some of these patients lack any objective findings by physical exam, X-ray, or laboratory tests. Nevertheless, they believe that their symptoms preclude employment. The origin of these ailments is mysterious. Patients with fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, and whiplash injury are among this group, and deciding whether these patients should be considered for disability is both controversial and vexing. Lacking better explanation for the desire of these patients not to work, the term “secondary gain” is often used.

What is secondary gain? In common parlance, it refers to the benefits or advantages that can accrue from not working. These may include money, freedom from a demanding or boring job, and leisure time for enjoyable activities. All of these benefits are supposedly made better by knowing that a generous check will arrive in the mail every month to pay the bills.

ad goes here:advert-2
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE

For some patients, the situation is more complicated because secondary gain may represent a desire for control and leverage to pressure family for attention and care. This dynamic can even extend to the physician as pressure to recommend disability. Suffice it to say, physicians do not like this. Applying the term “secondary gain” to a patient can convey a negative sentiment, often accompanied by annoyance and condescension from the provider. It can also lead to a blame game, in which patients are blamed for their symptoms and desire for disability.

Not Everyone Gains

Clearly, there are patients with arthritis who want to work but have trouble on the job. Even if the jobs are tough and pay little, these people want to keep at it. There is little secondary gain in disability for these people. I can remember a man with a back stiffened with ankylosing spondylitis whose work involved climbing a ladder to stock merchandise in a hardware store. My patient loved his job and took pride in knowing the locations of wire brads and cotter pins on high-up shelves.

Pages: 1 2 3 | Single Page

Filed Under: Opinion, Rheuminations, Soft Tissue Pain Tagged With: Arthritis, chronic fatigue syndrome, CME, Fibromyalgia, Pain, Patients, whiplashIssue: February 2008

You Might Also Like:
  • Hospitalists Gain Insight on Signs, Symptoms of Infection Among Inpatients on Biologic Drugs
  • No Gain with Pain: Exercise & Physical Function in Patients with Rheumatic Disease
  • Rheumatologists Saw a Gain in Compensation in 2020
  • Chronic Reactive Arthritis Secondary to Intravesical Bacillus Calmette–Guerin in Bladder Carcinoma

American College of Rheumatology

Visit the official website for the American College of Rheumatology.

Visit the ACR »

Meeting Abstracts

Browse and search abstracts from the ACR Convergence and ACR/ARP Annual Meetings going back to 2012.

Visit the Abstracts site »

ACR Convergence

Don’t miss rheumatology’s premier scientific meeting for anyone involved in research or the delivery of rheumatologic care or services.

Visit the ACR Convergence site »

The Rheumatologist newsmagazine reports on issues and trends in the management and treatment of rheumatic diseases. The Rheumatologist reaches 11,500 rheumatologists, internists, orthopedic surgeons, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, nurses, and other healthcare professionals who practice, research, or teach in the field of rheumatology.

About Us / Contact Us / Advertise / Privacy Policy / Terms of Use / Cookie Preferences

  • Connect with us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Feed

Copyright © 2006–2023 American College of Rheumatology. All rights reserved.

ISSN 1931-3268 (print)
ISSN 1931-3209 (online)